YEH HAI MUMBAI MERI JAAN

May 13 2008  | Views 422 |  Comments  (9)
I grew up in the 1950’s in a city called Bombay. It certainly could not rival London or New Yo... Expand

Leave a Comment   Flat Nested


  Rajan Roy posted 2 mnths ago

Well done Bha. I'm proud of you.



  Rajan Roy posted 3 mnths ago

Very subtle, tongue-in-cheek - and it gets the point home, without having to shout it from the rooftops!!

Rajan



  Girdhar Gopal posted 3 mnths ago

Philippi: Why is it that politicians use the short cut and rename cities,streets and what not to commemorate past heroes,rather than improving the economic and social lot of the people ?

      Fascists of every ilk, be they in Tamil Nadu, of the Dravida kind, or  in Bombay of the Maratha kind, know how to  exclude people and create scapegoats.. Hatred is a stock in trade, that these  people use to make minorities as objects of derision. Shivaji, their hero was the very opposite. His heart as wide as the great outdoors. He fought against Islamic oppression and carved out an empire, but he did not hate Muslims

     Marathis, North Indians,South Indians, Hindus, Muslims and what not have equal rights to live where they want including in  Bombay or Mumbai . I think the great cities of India should be declared as union territories with two languages established in each area: the local language and Hindi(or any second language chosen by all the people).
Regards, Girdhar



  anjaline- posted 3 mnths ago

Rightly written article. I remember the sainiks(?!) breaking the shops on valentine's day, the pass system at Siddhivinayak temple(!), changing names to unpronouncable ones, etc. What's the productivity. Go and build a school. my friend!  Please try to join rehabilitation centres for that drinking habit! Because, your wives are pleading Father Joseph and Mother Lucy for the admissions of your children and for some decent job for you! Just stop changing names. Change your attitude.

Ok. rant over.

A good write, really :)

Regards,
a



  Fernandes E E posted 3 mnths ago

Dear Phillipi,

Must say I enjoyed your tongue in cheek piece.

Edwin F



  B S Keshav posted 3 mnths ago

Good one... loved the sarcasm! 

When one can't think of anything good to do about the city, one just steps out and bashes up a couple of taxi drivers or Pani-puri wallahs from UP or Bihar. If that doesn't work, one can go and deface the boards of places that still use the evil word, "Bombay"... aah, now things will start working for sure! :-)

cheers,

Keshav



  Gopalkrishanan posted 3 mnths ago

A rose is a rose is a rose! whats in a name? Perhaps the marathi manoos might not understand. how cheap they are to call their own brethern as outsiders? Did n't they read our Pledge in which we say, "all Indians are my brothers and sisters".

Will we behave with our brothers and sisters like this? May be, they wanted these outsiders till they wanted to build a Mumbai. Once it is through, they do not want them here! With Marathi manoos they would have never built this Mumbai.

When it was Bombay, it was good but it turned into a bad place once it was changed to Mumbai. Will they realise this?



  Norik posted 3 mnths ago

It is true that some political parties may want to win political mileage out of acts like the name change of a city. At the same time it is not a bad thing to take pride in ones roots and therefore restore the original names of places. Peking became Beijing, Burma became Myanmar, the list goes on and on. So why not amchi Mumbai?! Ofcourse the hooliganism must stop and those who wish to use the name Bombay should not be violently attacked. But then isn't the Sena and now the MNS a party of hooligans run by a Don. Will someone explain the source of income for the one who lives in Kala Nagar with over a dozen cars? Likewise for the nephew whose children study at Bombay Scottish and yet whose party choses to disfigure the name of the school. I guess politicians make 'hay' because their followers are dumb enough to heed their instructions without giving a thought for what their master is really upto!



  ArjunN posted 3 mnths ago

Very true sir! But i'm sure Bombay or Mumbai.. whatever it is... wll survive





Leave a comment

Use normal text box:


Mumbai, Male
Member Since Sep 10 2007
© 1998-2008 Copyright Sulekha.com Connecting Indians Worldwide, All Rights Reserved.